A high match rate doesn’t necessarily mean better marketing performance. A third-party data provider might recognize most of your customers but still fall short when it comes to finding new prospects, reaching anonymous website visitors, or improving campaign targeting.

That’s where many data evaluations fall short. Marketing teams compare providers based on how much data they can match without first defining what they need that data to accomplish. The result can be an investment in data that looks valuable on paper but doesn’t support the business outcomes that matter.

A consumer services company faced this challenge as it looked to expand customer acquisition beyond paid search. Its customer data was spread across disconnected systems, limiting its ability to understand existing customers and identify new prospects with similar characteristics.

Actable, an Ekimetrics company, helped the business address both challenges. Working alongside the company’s engineering team, Actable helped establish a Customer Intelligence Hub while evaluating three third-party data providers against five specific marketing use cases.

The evaluation revealed an important distinction: the provider with the highest match coverage wasn’t the strongest choice for the company’s activation priorities. By evaluating each provider against the marketing activities it needed to support, the company identified a better fit for enrichment and prospecting while retaining its existing provider for customer understanding and measurement.

The Challenge: Customer Data Built to Run the Business, Not to Understand Customers

The company’s customer data lived in the systems that ran the business. Each system did its job, but none shared a customer ID, so marketing could not see one customer across all of them. Most website visitors were anonymous, and contact details were incomplete for part of the customer base.

Third-party customer data could help close those gaps. The challenge was determining which provider could support the company’s marketing priorities. Data providers often lead with match rates, showing how many customer records they can recognize. That number matters, but it does not tell you whether the data can do the jobs your marketing team needs done.

The Solution: Building Customer Intelligence While Evaluating Data Providers

Actable and the client ran two workstreams in parallel.

  • A Customer Intelligence Hub: one view of each customer, now run by the company’s own team.
  • A third-party data evaluation: three providers, each tested against the company’s customer data and scored on the company’s own use cases.

The two workstreams were connected. The third-party data evaluation used the same customer data foundation developed for the Customer Intelligence Hub.

How It Worked

Step 1: Define the Business Use Cases Before Evaluating Providers

Before any results came back, the team anchored the evaluation on five use cases:

  1. Customer acquisition: finding new prospects who resemble the company’s most valuable customers
  2. Cross-channel demand generation: reaching people across paid and digital channels, not just search
  3. Retention: keeping customers who show signs of leaving
  4. Anonymous visitor activation: reaching website visitors who have not identified themselves
  5. Timely campaigns: reaching the right audiences when demand peaks

Every provider would be judged on how well it supported these jobs.

Step 2: Build the Customer View in Parallel

While the evaluation ran, Actable’s Customer Intelligence Hub used customer identity resolution to bring the company’s records together into a unified customer view. Personal data stays protected inside the company’s environment. The team also developed customer value and churn scores, giving marketing a clearer view of customer value and potential retention risks.

The work was shared. The company’s engineers built the underlying infrastructure and data ingestion. Actable developed the predictive models and audience outputs and contributed design and configuration.

Step 3: Evaluate Each Provider Against the Company’s Customer Data

Each provider matched a file of the company’s customer records against its own data. The files differed in size, so the reported match rates were not a controlled comparison. More to the point, all three providers recognized a large share of the company’s customers. Match coverage alone could not separate them.

Step 4: Score Each Provider Against Each Use Case

The meaningful differences emerged when each provider was evaluated against the company’s marketing use cases.

  • Provider A had the highest match coverage. It was strongest for understanding customers, adding modeling features and measurement, but offered little for anonymous visitor activation.
  • Provider B had the lowest match coverage. It returned considerably more ways to reach each matched customer, such as mobile ad IDs, emails and phone numbers, and was the only provider able to identify anonymous website visitors in real time.
  • Provider C offered the deepest behavioral and lifestyle data, plus file cleanup services, which suited timely campaigns.

One caution shaped how the team read these results. More identifiers is not the same as more customers. Several identifiers often belong to the same person, so Provider B’s extra identifiers meant more ways to reach customers it had already matched, not necessarily a larger audience.

Scored against the five use cases, the provider with the weakest match coverage was actually the strongest overall fit for the company’s activation priorities. The provider with the highest coverage was the best fit for understanding and measurement. The right provider depended on the marketing outcomes the company needed to support.

Step 5: Weigh Legal and Consent Readiness Alongside Capability

Technical fit was only one part of the evaluation. Each option was also reviewed for legal requirements, data-use permissions and the company’s consent readiness. These were not trade-offs against capability. They were conditions an option had to meet before its data could be activated, because data the company cannot use with confidence has no value to marketing.

The Results: What the Company Has Now and What It Decided

Capabilities Delivered

  • A production Customer Intelligence Hub, refreshed in near real-time.
  • One view of each customer, with value and churn scores for the customers the models cover.
  • A working path to send privacy-safe audiences to ad platforms, currently in a testing phase before those audiences guide bidding.

Decisions Made

  • The company retained its measurement provider for customer understanding and measurement.
  • The company selected a different provider to pursue for enrichment and prospecting.

What It Means for the Business

The value of this work wasn’t simply identifying a data provider with better capabilities. It was giving the company a way to evaluate data investments against specific marketing objectives.

With a unified customer view and predictive scores in place, the company has a stronger foundation for understanding customer value, identifying retention opportunities, and developing more targeted acquisition strategies. The provider evaluation also established a clearer basis for deciding which external data capabilities are worth pursuing.

The broader lesson is straightforward: start with the business outcomes, evaluate providers against those requirements, and confirm that the data can be used responsibly before investing in activation.

What’s Next

Planned, not yet done:

  • Testing enrichment and prospecting with the selected provider, with consent requirements in place first
  • Using customer value scores to guide media bidding
  • Running retention tests with holdout groups so results can be measured

Make Your Data Investments Work Harder

A high match rate is only valuable if the data helps you achieve your marketing objectives. Actable helps brands evaluate third-party data against real business use cases, connect customer intelligence to activation, and make more informed investment decisions.

Schedule a call to discuss how to evaluate your customer data strategy.

Frequently Asked Questions About Third-Party Customer Data

What is third-party customer data?

Third-party customer data is information collected by an organization that does not have a direct relationship with the customer. Businesses can use this data to supplement their first-party customer information, better understand their audiences, and support marketing activities such as acquisition, targeting, and measurement.

What is a match rate in third-party data?

A match rate measures the percentage of customer records a data provider can recognize or connect to its own data. While match rates help evaluate coverage, they do not necessarily indicate how useful the matched data will be for specific marketing activities.

Why isn’t a high match rate enough to evaluate a data provider?

A high match rate shows how many customer records a provider can recognize, but it does not demonstrate whether the provider can support acquisition, audience activation, enrichment, or measurement. Marketing teams should evaluate match coverage alongside data quality, available identifiers, activation capabilities, and business use cases.

How should companies evaluate third-party data providers?

Companies should begin by defining the marketing outcomes they want to achieve. They can then compare providers based on match coverage, data enrichment capabilities, available activation channels, relevant customer attributes, and legal and consent requirements. Testing providers against the company’s own customer data helps identify which options best support those objectives.

How can third-party data improve customer acquisition?

Third-party data can help businesses identify additional prospects, enrich existing customer profiles, and expand audience targeting beyond their current channels. Its effectiveness depends on the quality and relevance of the data, the provider’s activation capabilities, and whether the data can be used in accordance with applicable legal and consent requirements.